Page 1 of 1

Lowering exhaust noise on K-Series

Posted: Mon Jul 09, 2012 1:55 pm
by PTWannaHave
Hello all,

My recently refurbished 125 is probably not that much louder than when it was new, but significantly louder than a more modern unit such as my 2185. (I know, it's not a fair comparison...!!) Nonetheless, I would like to significantly reduce the exhaust noise (even though it may only represent 1/2 of the 'total noise') without reducing power if possible.

The best ideas I have found so far are:

- SuperTrap brand (short stack) muffler
- Using a motorcycle stock muffler (new take-off) that has been replaced by a new owner with a performance muffler. (Quite common, I think. This may be the less expensive option of the two...)

Thank-you in advance,

Re: Lowering exhaust noise on K-Series

Posted: Mon Jul 09, 2012 5:06 pm
by Farmallgray
Maybe try what David Kirk did on his QL;
http://www.kirkengines.com/downloads/Ki ... PartII.pdf
It is about 1/3 down the page.

On the newer tractors the deck is a lot louder which may make the engine seem quieter.

Re: Lowering exhaust noise on K-Series

Posted: Wed Jul 11, 2012 12:20 pm
by PTWannaHave
Thanks Farmallgray.

I am still looking for a bolt-on solution, but may go go the Kirk route if I get desperate...

I added some cushioning to the hood recently to protect the new paint from rubbing off. Welcomed side-effect: noticeable reduced operating noise! :shock:

Cheers,

Re: Lowering exhaust noise on K-Series

Posted: Thu Nov 01, 2012 9:55 pm
by DaveKamp
If you look at the changes between the WF and QL series, you'll notice that a bulk of the QL changes all come back to preventing things from rattling and banging.

The next, is putting shrouding over as much as possible, making the shrouding fit down tight against some sort of snubbing surface (so no rattles) and this also contains most of the noise INSIDE the compartments, so it doesn't come out.

After that, is muffler noise.

Realize that many people seem to think the QL mower decks and implements are louder than the older style... most of the time, this is simply because the running noise of the machine is so much lower, that the deck and implements are much more noticeable. :mrgreen:

The K-series engine, being a big single, creates some pretty substantial primary and secondary vibration. In a rigid frame, this turns every other structural member into a mechanical linkage, and every flat surface into a speaker. Mounting it on a soft cradle helps substantially... however, if you've got a mean, strong K-single, it'll make pretty quick work of the iso-mounts... (don't ask me how I know)... having said cradle inside a flexible frame chews 'em apart even quicker, as the working machine gets pretty flexible when traversing the ground with a deeply-engaged implement... so if you do a mod on your machine, keep this all in-mind, and have some sort of secondary restraint in-place so that the motor can't take a long walk in case an iso-mount goes bad.

Keeping flat surfaces from becoming speakers is a DIFFICULT job. One of the techniques used in the NVH abatement field, is to apply heavy material to the backside of a flat surface. By adding mass, it lowers the surface's rattling frequency, and increases substantially the amount of energy required to make it shake. Not much room on most Cub Cadets to do things like that, but something to consider. I haven't done it on a Cub, but I HAVE employed spray-on undercoating to do just this sort of thing... and I've also used spray-on bedliner (the rattle-can variety) to help dampen and contain noise in things like boat engine covers... and it does work. Softer dampening materials are much better than hard-surface, as harder-surfaces reflect high-frequency noise.

Now, if you've got a really strong motor, you'll probably find that typical aftermarket mufflers of today simply don't last too long... Few that I've found were anywhere near the durability of OEM units. Making them control the noise is even more difficult, but I frequenly silence stationary engines considerably by using two mufflers, spread out with a few feet of pipe between 'em. Not something that's readily attainable within the confines of a typical working IH Cub Cadet, but it all depends on the constraints of your needs and the project.

:ugeek:

Re: Lowering exhaust noise on K-Series

Posted: Sat Nov 03, 2012 10:01 pm
by PTWannaHave
Thanks Dave; all useful comments/info!

I plan to rebuild a 14hp 'properly'. It may turn out to have a bit more Ooomph! than original, but nothing extravagant.

I am also thinking that a balanced rotating assembly (if that can be found for a K-series engine) may also be of great help by reducing the main source/cause of the vibrations...

I keep hearing that ISO engine mounts have a somewhat short lifespan, so I am not currently planning to use them. Then again, with a balanced rotating assembly, perhaps they would last...?!

Bye for now,

Re: Lowering exhaust noise on K-Series

Posted: Sat Nov 03, 2012 11:07 pm
by BigMike
Ben,K series Kohlers CAN be precision balanced.The flywheel is easy,spin it and drill where needed.The crank is another story.The majority of our K series cranks do not have matched counter weights.....one is usually thicker than the other.To do a proper balance job the crank needs to have the cheek machined flat and additional weight added then it can be spun and drilled as needed.I had a flywheel done and may have a crank done before the engine goes together.

ISO mounts have a short life span when in a machine that is neglected and abused.Most of us don't use our Cubs daily and even when we do we know them well and take care of them as needed.I believe with good ISO mounts and a front and rear cradle up grade the ISO will last a long time.
I know there are two camps on Quiet Lines.......I firmly stand in the one that likes em :mrgreen: