diesel vs gas tractor value

This is where we can discuss all the stuff made after IH's sale to MTD.
Post Reply
User avatar
drcjv
Posts: 70
Joined: Mon Jan 16, 2012 11:59 am
First and Last Name: Charles Venezia
Location: Fairview Village, PA

diesel vs gas tractor value

Post by drcjv »

Recently a very very nice 1872 was for sale near me. It was one of the nicest I ever saw. It sold in less than 24hrs for full price $2000. No 3pnt, rear pto or deck just tractor.This got me thinking what would an equally equipped and conditioned 1572 or 1772 be worth. I have been told a diesel is worth$1000 more than a gas version. Now add a 3pnt and /or a rear pto and deck which all together should be worth at least another $1000 and your up to $4000. What's your oppinion?
1572 3pnt rear PTO 50" deck, 1772 3pnt 50" deck, 1872 3pnt 44" deck, 2072 50" deck, three brinly 3pnt plows, 54 inch snow plow, cat 0 york rake.

LFR
Posts: 351
Joined: Fri Jan 17, 2014 4:28 pm
First and Last Name: Lorin Burch
Location: Boyne City, MI

Re: diesel vs gas tractor value

Post by LFR »

It all veries because diesel although worth more generally if the tractor was produced in 100s of thousands then it may not be worth as much as one model with only 10000 made so it really varies between hours and production numbers :beer:
67 Case 155, 66 Colt 2310, 68 John Deere 110w/ haban sickle bar mower, 59 simplicity 700 wonderboy, 62 allis Chalmers b1, Fairbanksmorse 3 wheel, 1944 McCormick peering O4, H, 1948 Farmall Cub, C.

User avatar
ksanders
Posts: 930
Joined: Mon Sep 06, 2010 2:56 pm
First and Last Name: Kevin Sanders
Location: Sellersburg, Indiana

Re: diesel vs gas tractor value

Post by ksanders »

Someone must have wanted it badly I guess. When I had my 1572 late last year I never got a single offer at $3000 and very few at $2500 and they were borderline insulting. People offering 1500-1800 when I was at 3000. I got mad and hung up on multiple occasions trying to get rid of a nice tractor I used weekly all while trying to sell. Even plowed my garden with it the week before it did sell. Tractor had 3 pt, ags, 50" deck,turning brakes, power steering, front blade, low hours. I went through months of annoyance to sell it for barely more than what the tractor you're talking about sold for and had to sell the deck and weights separate with the hitch and options about to go next . Just something to compare with. I thought diesels were worth a lot to but the reality is when you get into the thousands it's hard to get what anything is worth nowadays.
From the first Original to the last x82 Series... you can't beat an IH Cub Cadet!!!

User avatar
drcjv
Posts: 70
Joined: Mon Jan 16, 2012 11:59 am
First and Last Name: Charles Venezia
Location: Fairview Village, PA

Re: diesel vs gas tractor value

Post by drcjv »

There may be a differance in price depending where you are located. I have seen this 1872 go for $2000, another 1872 with deck go for $2175, a 982 with rear pto, 3pnt and deck for $2625 and another rougher 1872 with deck for $1800. The guy that bought the one for $2000 drove 3hrs and paid full price and the seller had a bunch of emails he did not even answer the tractor sold in about 12 hrs. I thought the 982 was worth more. I would not sell one of my diesels for less than $3000 especially the 1772. I guess it does not matter because they are not for sale.
1572 3pnt rear PTO 50" deck, 1772 3pnt 50" deck, 1872 3pnt 44" deck, 2072 50" deck, three brinly 3pnt plows, 54 inch snow plow, cat 0 york rake.

User avatar
Racenitro
Posts: 354
Joined: Tue Sep 07, 2010 10:31 pm
First and Last Name: Frank S. Morski
Location: O'Fallon, Il

Re: diesel vs gas tractor value

Post by Racenitro »

It must be the part of the country because I have a bunch of Gas and Diesel supers up for sale and NO bites!
I did sell 90% of my parts and implements over the last two weeks. Sent three trailer loads down the road.
All that is left are the supers one original, chipper shredders and a few other items.
I never figured I'd sell the parts but a guy that bought a bunch of tractors 3 or 4 years back bought the parts.

User avatar
drcjv
Posts: 70
Joined: Mon Jan 16, 2012 11:59 am
First and Last Name: Charles Venezia
Location: Fairview Village, PA

Re: diesel vs gas tractor value

Post by drcjv »

Frank what supers do you have and how much do you want?
1572 3pnt rear PTO 50" deck, 1772 3pnt 50" deck, 1872 3pnt 44" deck, 2072 50" deck, three brinly 3pnt plows, 54 inch snow plow, cat 0 york rake.

User avatar
SWilliams
Posts: 806
Joined: Mon Sep 06, 2010 7:14 pm
First and Last Name: Steve Williams
Location: Fort Plain NY (Upstate NY near Cooperstown)

Re: diesel vs gas tractor value

Post by SWilliams »

Frank, got any water cooled gas supers? I'd like a second.. Then to figure out how to get it here..
Owner of an 1863, 2263 (1863 W 22hp engine!) 2084 and a 2 - 2284s.


"In God we trust, All others pay CASH..."

Post Reply